Browse · MathNet
PrintNorth Macedonia
North Macedonia number theory
Problem
Find all natural numbers and greater than , such that .
Solution
Let be the least prime factor of , and be the least natural number such that (such a number exists because ). From Little Fermat's theorem, we have that , which implies and , and from the minimality of , we get that , i.e. . Let , where is not divisible by . If , then , so , for every natural number from and , so the degree of in is and therefore we get that . The last is not possible because for , and , it holds that .
This implies that, the degree of in must be . If , we will prove that the degree of in is , for every natural number . For , the statement is true. Let the statement be true for every . For from the following equalities and we get that (where and and coprime by the assumption) with which we've proved the statement by induction. From the equality and from , we get that the degree of in is , and on the other hand it must be greater or equal to , which is possible only for and , but this case is not possible because of .
Now, the case when remains. From the equality (the same as above for ) The fact that is odd implies that is an odd number as a sum of an odd number of odd numbers ( has to be odd, because ). From and , we get that , for every natural number , but this implies that is not a divisor of . This implies that the degree of in is , so because , we get that , and because can be a divisor of only one of and , we get that , which is possible if and only if or . Let be the least prime factor of , , and are coprime and is the least natural number for which . This implies that and (the same as before for ). This is possible only if or (those are the only divisors of , less than ). In both cases , which is possible only for , a contradiction with the choice of . We get that the unique solution is and ().
This implies that, the degree of in must be . If , we will prove that the degree of in is , for every natural number . For , the statement is true. Let the statement be true for every . For from the following equalities and we get that (where and and coprime by the assumption) with which we've proved the statement by induction. From the equality and from , we get that the degree of in is , and on the other hand it must be greater or equal to , which is possible only for and , but this case is not possible because of .
Now, the case when remains. From the equality (the same as above for ) The fact that is odd implies that is an odd number as a sum of an odd number of odd numbers ( has to be odd, because ). From and , we get that , for every natural number , but this implies that is not a divisor of . This implies that the degree of in is , so because , we get that , and because can be a divisor of only one of and , we get that , which is possible if and only if or . Let be the least prime factor of , , and are coprime and is the least natural number for which . This implies that and (the same as before for ). This is possible only if or (those are the only divisors of , less than ). In both cases , which is possible only for , a contradiction with the choice of . We get that the unique solution is and ().
Final answer
(a, b) = (3, 2)
Techniques
Factorization techniquesFermat / Euler / Wilson theoremsMultiplicative order