Browse · MathNet
PrintEstonian Mathematical Olympiad
Estonia number theory
Problem
Find all positive integers such that is not divisible by .
Solution
For any prime , as prime occurs only once in the prime factorization of . Additionally, does not divide . We will show that for all other positive integers . Let be a prime factor of , and the exponent of in the prime factorization of . If there exists a different prime factor of , then both and are in the set of integers from 1 to and hence . This holds for all prime factors of .
Thus divides for all with at least two distinct prime factors. Now consider the remaining integers for prime . For all three integers , , and are distinct factors in , implying that divides . For and the integers , , and are distinct factors in , implying that divides .
---
Alternative solution.
We find all positive integers such that ; obviously this condition is equivalent to that of the problem. For prime , no integer less than can have a prime factor and thus cannot divide . For , 4 does not divide . On the other hand, for where is prime, the integers and are in the set of integers from 1 to , implying . If is a cube or a higher power of some prime, or has at least two prime factors, then it obviously has a divisor such that and (e.g. the smallest prime factor of ). Hence and are distinct positive integers less than and their product divides .
Thus divides for all with at least two distinct prime factors. Now consider the remaining integers for prime . For all three integers , , and are distinct factors in , implying that divides . For and the integers , , and are distinct factors in , implying that divides .
---
Alternative solution.
We find all positive integers such that ; obviously this condition is equivalent to that of the problem. For prime , no integer less than can have a prime factor and thus cannot divide . For , 4 does not divide . On the other hand, for where is prime, the integers and are in the set of integers from 1 to , implying . If is a cube or a higher power of some prime, or has at least two prime factors, then it obviously has a divisor such that and (e.g. the smallest prime factor of ). Hence and are distinct positive integers less than and their product divides .
Final answer
All prime numbers and 4
Techniques
Prime numbersFactorization techniques