Browse · MathNet
PrintGirls European Mathematical Olympiad
North Macedonia geometry
Problem
Let be the orthocentre and be the centroid of acute-angled triangle with . The line intersects the circumcircle of at and . Let be the reflection of in the line . Prove that if and only if .
Solution
Let be the circumcircle of . Reflecting in line , we obtain circle which, obviously, contains points and . Let be the midpoint of . As triangle is acute-angled, then and lie inside this triangle.
Let us assume that . Since hence lies on . Reflecting in line , we obtain point which lies on and this point is the center of . Then , so , where is the radius of and, naturally, of . Then quadrilateral is a rhombus, so and are symmetric to each other with respect to . As and are collinear (Euler line), then . Diagonals of quadrilateral intersect at . Since , so As , then is cyclic. Since is a perpendicular bisector of , so the circumcircle of quadrilateral is symmetrical with respect to . Thus also belongs to the circumcircle of , hence . Note that since . And as it was proved , then . Thus triangles and are equal and hence .
Now we will prove that if then . Reflecting with respect to , we get . Then, as it was said in the first part of solution, points and belong to . Also it is clear that belongs to . Note that since and hence is a diameter of . Obviously, the center of circle is midpoint of . From it follows that is equal to . Therefore and are symmetric with respect to . Hence and . Let intersect at and since . We conclude that , because line is midline of the triangle . Note that , since is Euler line of triangle . So is midpoint of segment . Because of , then . Line , that passes through , is an external angle bisector of . Also we know that, then is the midpoint of arc . It follows that quadrilateral is cyclic, then . Let and intersect at . Triangles and are similar, hence . In other words, . Using Menelaus' theorem for triangle and line , we obtain that It follows that and . Using Menelaus' theorem for triangle and line we get It means that , so . Hence and consequently, . Finally we conclude that , so .
---
Alternative solution.
Let and denote the reflection of and respectively, with respect to the line . We then need to show iff . Note that is isosceles and hence is equivalent to lying on the bisector . Let . By the assumption , we have . Then , hence iff . But . Let be the midpoint of . It is known that . Let be the midpoint of . Then (Euler line). Let . We then have to show iff . But by similarity () we have . Consider the circumcircles of the triangles and . By the sine law and since the segments and are of equal length we deduce that the circumcircles of the triangles and are symmetric with respect to the perpendicular bisector of the segment iff . Obviously, is the common point of these two circles. Hence must be fixed after the symmetry about the perpendicular bisector of the segment .
we have iff is isosceles. But , and so
---
Alternative solution.
Let and denote the reflection of points and with respect to the line . It is known that belongs to the circumcircle of . The equality is equivalent to . As in the solution 2, it is equivalent to the statement that point belongs to the perpendicular bisector of , which is equivalent to , where is the circumcenter of .
Let points , , and belong to the unit circle in the complex plane. Point has coordinate . Since is parallel to the real axis, point has coordinate .
Point belongs to the unit circle, so . Since are collinear we have After computation we get . Since is the reflection of with respect to the chord , we have . Let . We have . So It is easy to see that is equivalent to since and belong to the unit circle (note that because ). This is equivalent to and from (1), after easy computations, this is equivalent to We cannot have , because then , but . Hence , and the pair is either or . Both cases are equivalent to which completes the proof.
Let us assume that . Since hence lies on . Reflecting in line , we obtain point which lies on and this point is the center of . Then , so , where is the radius of and, naturally, of . Then quadrilateral is a rhombus, so and are symmetric to each other with respect to . As and are collinear (Euler line), then . Diagonals of quadrilateral intersect at . Since , so As , then is cyclic. Since is a perpendicular bisector of , so the circumcircle of quadrilateral is symmetrical with respect to . Thus also belongs to the circumcircle of , hence . Note that since . And as it was proved , then . Thus triangles and are equal and hence .
Now we will prove that if then . Reflecting with respect to , we get . Then, as it was said in the first part of solution, points and belong to . Also it is clear that belongs to . Note that since and hence is a diameter of . Obviously, the center of circle is midpoint of . From it follows that is equal to . Therefore and are symmetric with respect to . Hence and . Let intersect at and since . We conclude that , because line is midline of the triangle . Note that , since is Euler line of triangle . So is midpoint of segment . Because of , then . Line , that passes through , is an external angle bisector of . Also we know that, then is the midpoint of arc . It follows that quadrilateral is cyclic, then . Let and intersect at . Triangles and are similar, hence . In other words, . Using Menelaus' theorem for triangle and line , we obtain that It follows that and . Using Menelaus' theorem for triangle and line we get It means that , so . Hence and consequently, . Finally we conclude that , so .
---
Alternative solution.
Let and denote the reflection of and respectively, with respect to the line . We then need to show iff . Note that is isosceles and hence is equivalent to lying on the bisector . Let . By the assumption , we have . Then , hence iff . But . Let be the midpoint of . It is known that . Let be the midpoint of . Then (Euler line). Let . We then have to show iff . But by similarity () we have . Consider the circumcircles of the triangles and . By the sine law and since the segments and are of equal length we deduce that the circumcircles of the triangles and are symmetric with respect to the perpendicular bisector of the segment iff . Obviously, is the common point of these two circles. Hence must be fixed after the symmetry about the perpendicular bisector of the segment .
we have iff is isosceles. But , and so
---
Alternative solution.
Let and denote the reflection of points and with respect to the line . It is known that belongs to the circumcircle of . The equality is equivalent to . As in the solution 2, it is equivalent to the statement that point belongs to the perpendicular bisector of , which is equivalent to , where is the circumcenter of .
Let points , , and belong to the unit circle in the complex plane. Point has coordinate . Since is parallel to the real axis, point has coordinate .
Point belongs to the unit circle, so . Since are collinear we have After computation we get . Since is the reflection of with respect to the chord , we have . Let . We have . So It is easy to see that is equivalent to since and belong to the unit circle (note that because ). This is equivalent to and from (1), after easy computations, this is equivalent to We cannot have , because then , but . Hence , and the pair is either or . Both cases are equivalent to which completes the proof.
Techniques
Triangle centers: centroid, incenter, circumcenter, orthocenter, Euler line, nine-point circleCyclic quadrilateralsMenelaus' theoremComplex numbers in geometryAngle chasingTrigonometry