Browse · MathNet
PrintUkrainian Mathematical Competitions
Ukraine counting and probability
Problem
For which of the sets or is there a function such that the condition is satisfied? (Andrii Anikushin)
Solution
Suppose that the set is more than countable set. Divide half-plane to the counted number of rectangles: By construction, , in addition, any two of determined earlier rectangles do not intersect. Consider the graph of the function . Because is more than countable, the set is also more than countable (). Suppose that (i.e. the set ) is finite, but then the whole set is at most countable, that contradicts its construction. Therefore, is infinite set. This means that there is an infinite set such that . Then due to Bolzano-Weierstrass theorem there is a sequence of different elements that converges to some number. As a result, this sequence is fundamental and . But then we have the following relationship: and , which contradicts the problem's condition.
Thereby, should be no more than countable. Now determine the required function. Let . Define the function by induction: . Now let us know . Let us make the following notation: . Let's set . We should verify that the function which is defined for satisfies the conditions of the problem.
Example: for : if , where , , (), we will set . Then if we have:
Thereby, should be no more than countable. Now determine the required function. Let . Define the function by induction: . Now let us know . Let us make the following notation: . Let's set . We should verify that the function which is defined for satisfies the conditions of the problem.
Example: for : if , where , , (), we will set . Then if we have:
Final answer
Only for A = Q; no such function exists for A = R.
Techniques
OtherGreatest common divisors (gcd)