Skip to main content
OlympiadHQ

Browse · MathNet

Print

49th International Mathematical Olympiad Spain

number theory

Problem

Let be distinct positive integers, . Prove that there exist distinct indices and such that does not divide any of the numbers .
Solution
Without loss of generality, let . One can also assume that are coprime. Otherwise division by their greatest common divisor reduces the question to the new sequence whose terms are coprime integers.

Suppose that the claim is false. Then for each there exists a such that divides . If is not divisible by then divides which is impossible as . Thus is a multiple of for , so that are all congruent (to ) modulo .

Now is not divisible by or else so would be all remaining 's, meaning that are not coprime. Hence where , and for all .

Consider a sum where . There is at least one such sum as . Let be an index such that divides . Observe that is not divisible by since . It follows that divides , in particular . Hence , implying . So is divisible by all sums , . In particular for .

Let be such that divides . If then . This yields ; however for . Therefore or .

For we obtain with an integer, and it is straightforward that ( and contradict ; leads to ). Thus , i.e. .

Similarly, if then for some integer , and only is possible. Hence holds true in both cases remaining, and .

Now implies that the sum is strictly between and . But and are distinct as , so it follows from the above that divides . This provides the desired contradiction.

Techniques

Greatest common divisors (gcd)IntegersOther