Browse · MathNet
PrintEstonian Math Competitions
Estonia algebra
Problem
There are some distinct positive integers written on a blackboard. If we erase the smallest number written on the blackboard, then the ratio of the sum and the product of the remaining numbers will be 4 times greater than the ratio of the sum and the product of the numbers initially on the blackboard. Find all possibilities for the set of numbers that could have been on the blackboard initially.
Solution
Answer: .
Clearly there must be at least 2 numbers. Let be the smallest number, the sum and the product of the remaining numbers. We get the equation . Multiplying by , we get , which rearranges to . We know that and , as was the smallest number on the blackboard. This leaves the options and (note that negative factors would also yield negative and/or ). So and or and .
Let and . If there are initially 2 numbers, they must be and . If there are 3 numbers, they could be and or and or and or and . There can't be 4 or more numbers, because .
Let and . If there are initially 2 numbers, they must be and . There can't be 3 or more numbers, because .
Clearly there must be at least 2 numbers. Let be the smallest number, the sum and the product of the remaining numbers. We get the equation . Multiplying by , we get , which rearranges to . We know that and , as was the smallest number on the blackboard. This leaves the options and (note that negative factors would also yield negative and/or ). So and or and .
Let and . If there are initially 2 numbers, they must be and . If there are 3 numbers, they could be and or and or and or and . There can't be 4 or more numbers, because .
Let and . If there are initially 2 numbers, they must be and . There can't be 3 or more numbers, because .
Final answer
{5, 20}; {5, 6, 14}; {5, 7, 13}; {5, 8, 12}; {5, 9, 11}; {6, 12}
Techniques
IntegersFactorization techniques