Browse · MathNet
PrintCesko-Slovacko-Poljsko 2013
2013 algebra
Problem
For each rational number consider the statement: If is a real number such that and are rational numbers, then is rational as well.
a) Prove the statement for and for .
b) Let be different odd primes such that . Show the statement is false for .
a) Prove the statement for and for .
b) Let be different odd primes such that . Show the statement is false for .
Solution
a) Let and be rational. Then consequently if (which is ), then is rational. We conclude that the given statement holds iff the equation has no irrational roots. For the sake of completeness, note that if (1) has a rational root then and are rational as well: If the determinant of (1) is less or equal 0, then (1) has no real solutions or a solution , which is rational. Since or the statement under consideration is true.
b) According to a) it suffices to show that and is irrational. We have But thus and , that is is not a perfect square, that is is irrational.
b) According to a) it suffices to show that and is irrational. We have But thus and , that is is not a perfect square, that is is irrational.
Techniques
Quadratic functionsLinear and quadratic inequalitiesPrime numbers