jmc

Since the two horizontal lines are $5-2=3$ units apart, we know that the side of the square is $3$ units long. Therefore, the fourth line must be parallel to $x=1$. If $x=a$ is to the left of $x=1$, its equation is $x=1-3=-2$. If $x=a$ is to the right of $x=1$, then its equation is $x=1+3=4$. Therefore, the two values for $a$ are $4$ and $-2$, and their product is $\boxed{-8}$.