Browse · MathNet
PrintSlovenija 2008
Slovenia 2008 number theory
Problem
Let be a subset of the set of all natural numbers with the property that for any two numbers and in either divides or divides . Prove that every is greater than the sum of all those numbers in that are smaller than .
Solution
Denote the elements of the set by , so that . We will prove the claim by induction. Obviously, the sum of all numbers less than is equal to and is therefore less than .
Now, assume that for a positive integer we have . We show that a similar estimate holds for .
We have , so cannot be a divisor of and is a divisor of . So, there exists a positive integer such that . Since and are not equal, we have and by induction hypothesis. This inequality shows that the claim is true for and, by induction, for all positive integers.
Now, assume that for a positive integer we have . We show that a similar estimate holds for .
We have , so cannot be a divisor of and is a divisor of . So, there exists a positive integer such that . Since and are not equal, we have and by induction hypothesis. This inequality shows that the claim is true for and, by induction, for all positive integers.
Techniques
Divisibility / FactorizationInduction / smoothing