Browse · MathNet
Print58. National mathematical olympiad Final round
Bulgaria counting and probability
Problem
Planes through the points with integer coordinates in the three dimensional Euclidean space partition the space into unit cubes. Find all triples , , of positive integers such that the cubes can be colored in colors in such a way that every parallelepiped of dimensions , integer vertices and faces parallel to the coordinate planes does not contain cubes of the same color.
Solution
We shall prove that the solutions are the triples such that divides and divides . We denote by the parallelepiped with a low right vertex and dimensions and , at axes and , respectively.
Let us assume that is not divisible by , i.e. for some , . If is a permutation of , then it follows from the condition for the parallelepipeds and that the parallelepipeds and are filled with cubes of the same colors. This implies that the parallelepipeds and are also filled with cubes of the same colors and the same is true for the parallelepipeds and . Since contains and contains and , every color in appears at least two times in . This contradiction completes the proof that divides . We analogously see that divides .
Now let and , as , where . For every two positive integers and we denote by the remainder of modulo . The coordinates of a cube will be the coordinates of its low right vertex.
We determine the color the cube in remainders as follows: The counting of all possible remainders in the six coordinates shows that the number of the colors used is .
Let us assume that two distinct cubes and lie in a parallelepiped of dimensions . Then we have , and , where is a permutation of . Since , and are divisible by , one of these numbers equals . Let us have . Then the fourth and fifth coordinates of that color show that and are divisible by and therefore one of these two numbers equals . If, for example, , then the last coordinate shows that is divisible by , i.e. . We obtained , which is a contradiction.
Let us assume that is not divisible by , i.e. for some , . If is a permutation of , then it follows from the condition for the parallelepipeds and that the parallelepipeds and are filled with cubes of the same colors. This implies that the parallelepipeds and are also filled with cubes of the same colors and the same is true for the parallelepipeds and . Since contains and contains and , every color in appears at least two times in . This contradiction completes the proof that divides . We analogously see that divides .
Now let and , as , where . For every two positive integers and we denote by the remainder of modulo . The coordinates of a cube will be the coordinates of its low right vertex.
We determine the color the cube in remainders as follows: The counting of all possible remainders in the six coordinates shows that the number of the colors used is .
Let us assume that two distinct cubes and lie in a parallelepiped of dimensions . Then we have , and , where is a permutation of . Since , and are divisible by , one of these numbers equals . Let us have . Then the fourth and fifth coordinates of that color show that and are divisible by and therefore one of these two numbers equals . If, for example, , then the last coordinate shows that is divisible by , i.e. . We obtained , which is a contradiction.
Final answer
(a, b, c) with a | b and b | c
Techniques
Coloring schemes, extremal argumentsOther