Browse · MathNet
PrintBulgarian Winter Tournament
Bulgaria algebra
Problem
Given a rational number such that is the square of a rational number. The row is defined as follows:
Do there exist a natural number and nonzero integers such that and if we write the number in the form , where and are co-prime integers, then is the number free of squares?
Do there exist a natural number and nonzero integers such that and if we write the number in the form , where and are co-prime integers, then is the number free of squares?
Solution
We will prove that such numbers do not exist.
The quadratic equation has two rational roots and for which . It easily follows by induction that . Let's assume that there exist numbers satisfying the condition of the problem.
Lemma. Let be a polynomial with nonzero integer coefficients for which for each and . Then , where is a polynomial with integer coefficients.
Proof: From the condition we have that . As it follows that and therefore is a double root. The lemma is proved.
The polynomial satisfies the conditions of the lemma. It's not hard to see that Moreover, if , , then from it easily follows that , i.e. . Then is a number of the form .
Finally is presented in the form and because the number and , then the numerator will always square a prime number.
The quadratic equation has two rational roots and for which . It easily follows by induction that . Let's assume that there exist numbers satisfying the condition of the problem.
Lemma. Let be a polynomial with nonzero integer coefficients for which for each and . Then , where is a polynomial with integer coefficients.
Proof: From the condition we have that . As it follows that and therefore is a double root. The lemma is proved.
The polynomial satisfies the conditions of the lemma. It's not hard to see that Moreover, if , , then from it easily follows that , i.e. . Then is a number of the form .
Finally is presented in the form and because the number and , then the numerator will always square a prime number.
Techniques
Recurrence relationsPolynomial operationsFactorization techniques