Browse · MathNet
PrintDistrict Round
Czech Republic number theory
Problem
An online vote is being held between options and . Before Paul voted, the percentage of votes for option was a positive integer. Paul's vote increased this number by exactly one. Prove that Paul's vote was the nineteenth vote for option . (Josef Tkadlec)
Solution
Let the total number of votes before Paul voted be , and the number of votes for before Paul voted be . The percentage of votes for before Paul voted is , which is a positive integer. After Paul votes for , the number of votes for becomes , and the total number of votes becomes . The new percentage is . We are told that this new percentage is exactly one more than the previous percentage:
Let , so .
Substitute into the equation:
Multiply both sides by :
Recall that must be an integer, and and are positive integers with .
Let .
Then:
We need to be an integer, so is divisible by .
Let us try all from to (since and are positive integers):
We seek such that is divisible by .
Let us try :
, and (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (integer!).
So , , .
Check: Before Paul voted, , , so percentage is .
After Paul votes for , , , percentage is .
So the percentage increases by exactly .
Therefore, Paul's vote was the nineteenth vote for option .
Let , so .
Substitute into the equation:
Multiply both sides by :
Recall that must be an integer, and and are positive integers with .
Let .
Then:
We need to be an integer, so is divisible by .
Let us try all from to (since and are positive integers):
We seek such that is divisible by .
Let us try :
, and (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (not integer).
Try :
, (integer!).
So , , .
Check: Before Paul voted, , , so percentage is .
After Paul votes for , , , percentage is .
So the percentage increases by exactly .
Therefore, Paul's vote was the nineteenth vote for option .
Final answer
19
Techniques
Factorization techniquesSimple Equations