Browse · MathNet
PrintMacedonian Mathematical Olympiad
North Macedonia counting and probability
Problem
A total of coins are distributed among several children. If one of the children has at least half of the coins, the coins are redistributed: coins are transferred from such a child to each of the other children in such a way that each of them gets as many coins as it had. In the case when one child possesses all the coins there is no possibility for redistribution. What is the greatest number of consecutive redistributions? (For example, if coins are distributed among children in the following way: , , , , , , then after one redistribution the children will have: , , , , , coins, respectively; in the example, that number is ). Explain your answer!
Solution
At most consecutive redistributions. We will start with an example showing that consecutive redistributions are possible. Let coins be distributed among children initially as follows: , , . The successive redistributions (a total of ) will be: Let us show that is the maximal number of consecutive redistributions. We start by assuming that there is an initial distribution for which there are at least possible redistributions and we seek contradiction: let us note that after one redistribution the number of coins that each child has is divisible by (each child to whom coins have been added has a doubled number of coins which is an even number, and the child from whom coins have been taken has again an even number of coins since there is a total of coins i.e. an even number of them). Analogously after the second redistribution each child has a number of coins that is divisible by , and so on, until the -th redistribution in which the number of coins each child has is divisible by ; taking into account that the total number of coins is constant and equals , the only possible distribution (in some order) is . But then there cannot be a next redistribution. Contradiction!
Final answer
n
Techniques
Invariants / monovariantsInduction / smoothing