Browse · MathNet
PrintChina Mathematical Olympiad
China counting and probability
Problem
Let be a set of 56 elements. Find the least positive integer such that for any 15 subsets of , if the union of every 7 sets of these subsets contains at least elements, then there exist 3 of the 15 subsets whose intersection is nonempty. (posed by Leng Gangsong)
Solution
Suppose there exist 15 subsets of , the union of every 7 of these 15 subsets contains at least 41 elements, and there exists no 3 of the 15 subsets whose intersection is nonempty. Since every element of can only belong 2 of the 15 subsets, we can suppose that every element of belongs to exactly 2 of the 15 subsets. Otherwise we can add a few more elements to some sets of the 15 subsets, and the condition still holds. By the Pigeonhole Principle, there is a set of the 15 subsets (suppose it is ), such that . Let the other 14 sets be . The union of every 7 sets of contains at least 41 elements. So the total number .
We use another way to compute the value of . For , if , then belongs to exactly 2 sets of . So is counted times. If , then belongs to only one set of . So is counted times. It follows that that is, , a contradiction.
Next, we prove . If , suppose . let It is easy to see that For every 3 of the 15 subsets, there are 2 sets both being , or both being . So the intersection of the 3 sets is empty. But for every 7 of the 15 subsets, for example, we have So .
We use another way to compute the value of . For , if , then belongs to exactly 2 sets of . So is counted times. If , then belongs to only one set of . So is counted times. It follows that that is, , a contradiction.
Next, we prove . If , suppose . let It is easy to see that For every 3 of the 15 subsets, there are 2 sets both being , or both being . So the intersection of the 3 sets is empty. But for every 7 of the 15 subsets, for example, we have So .
Final answer
41
Techniques
Pigeonhole principleCounting two waysInclusion-exclusionColoring schemes, extremal arguments