Browse · MathNet
PrintSelection tests for the International Mathematical Olympiad 2013
Saudi Arabia 2013 counting and probability
Problem
Determine if there exists an infinite sequence of positive integers such that (i) each positive integer occurs exactly once in the sequence, and (ii) each positive integer occurs exactly once in the sequence
Solution
We will construct such a sequence by induction: Define and . In this case we have . Assume that are defined such that there is no positive integer which occurs at least twice neither in the finite sequence nor in the finite sequence . Let be the maximum element of the set of integers , the maximum of the integers such that , and the maximum of the integers such that . Notice that for all , we have If define and . If define and . It is clear that none of the two possible values for and for occur in the finite sequence . In the first case, we have and for all , and since . In the second case, we have and for all , and . Therefore, there is no positive integer which occurs at least twice in the finite sequence or in the finite sequence . This proves that there is no positive integer which occurs at least twice in the infinite sequence or in the infinite sequence . Notice moreover, that in the first case and in the second case . Therefore, if then . But and . We deduce that for all integer . Therefore, any positive integer occurs in both finite sequences and . This proves that any positive integer occurs exactly once in each infinite sequence and .
Final answer
Yes, such an infinite sequence exists.
Techniques
Induction / smoothingInvariants / monovariantsColoring schemes, extremal arguments