Browse · MathNet
Print2025 International Mathematical Olympiad China National Team Selection Test
China 2025 algebra
Problem
Let be real numbers, and let , , , be real sequences satisfying: (1) () are all zero; (2) () are not all zero; (3) For and any positive integer , where . Prove that there exists a positive real number and infinitely many positive integers such that
Solution
Proof: We first prove a lemma. Lemma: Let be a complex number. If a sequence satisfies , , and for all , then does not converge to . Proof of Lemma: Let be roots of , so . If , then and or . Clearly doesn't converge to . If , then with and (since , ). Case 1: . Then cannot converge to since . Case 2: . Let , . If , then is periodic and non-zero. If , then is dense modulo , making have values dense on some circle. In all cases, doesn't converge to . Now the main proof. Denote the given equations as . Case 1: . Define transformed sequences: where indices are cyclic modulo . These satisfy: ---
Thus we may assume . Let be a th root of unity and define: Then: Since not all , some . By the lemma, doesn't converge to . Case 2: If there exists some . Without loss of generality, assume . Then from we know that for any we have . If , applying the lemma to the sequence shows that does not converge to . If , then . Consequently, from we know that for any we have . In this case, if , we can apply the lemma to the sequence . If then , and similarly we obtain . Continuing this process, by induction we can prove that either all sequences in the problem are identically zero, or there exists at least one sequence that does not converge to . The former case contradicts the problem's assumptions, thus completing the proof.
Thus we may assume . Let be a th root of unity and define: Then: Since not all , some . By the lemma, doesn't converge to . Case 2: If there exists some . Without loss of generality, assume . Then from we know that for any we have . If , applying the lemma to the sequence shows that does not converge to . If , then . Consequently, from we know that for any we have . In this case, if , we can apply the lemma to the sequence . If then , and similarly we obtain . Continuing this process, by induction we can prove that either all sequences in the problem are identically zero, or there exists at least one sequence that does not converge to . The former case contradicts the problem's assumptions, thus completing the proof.
Techniques
Recurrence relationsComplex numbersRoots of unity