Browse · MathNet
PrintRomanian Mathematical Olympiad
Romania algebra
Problem
Let and be positive integers, and let be a group of order . Prove that the following two statements are equivalent: (a) The numbers and are relatively prime. (b) For every subgroup of , the set is contained in .
Solution
We show that (a) implies (b). Since and are relatively prime, for some integers and . Let be a subgroup of , and let be a member of such that . Since , the unit of , it follows that
We now show that (b) implies (a). This is clearly the case if or , so let them both be at least , and suppose, if possible, they share some prime divisor . By Cauchy's theorem, for some in .
Consider the trivial subgroup . Since is divisible by , it follows that , so ; that is, , contradicting the fact that lies in . Consequently, is indeed coprime to .
We now show that (b) implies (a). This is clearly the case if or , so let them both be at least , and suppose, if possible, they share some prime divisor . By Cauchy's theorem, for some in .
Consider the trivial subgroup . Since is divisible by , it follows that , so ; that is, , contradicting the fact that lies in . Consequently, is indeed coprime to .
Techniques
Group Theory