Skip to main content
OlympiadHQ

Browse · MathNet

Print

International Mathematical Olympiad

counting and probability

Problem

Let be an integer. Find the smallest integer with the property that there exists a set of distinct real numbers such that each of its elements can be written as a sum of other distinct elements of the set.
Solution
First we show that . Suppose that there exists such a set with numbers and denote them by . Note that in order to express as a sum of distinct elements of the set, we must have and, similarly for , we must have . We also know that . If then we have , which gives a contradiction. If then we have , that again gives a contradiction. If then we have and . Adding the two inequalities we get , again a contradiction. It remains to give an example of a set with elements satisfying the condition of the problem. We start with the case when and . In that case, denote by and take the set , which has exactly elements. We are left to show that this set satisfies the required condition. Note that if a number can be expressed in the desired way, then so can by negating the expression. Therefore, we consider only . If , we sum the numbers from some sets with , and the numbers and . For , we sum the numbers from some sets with , and the numbers and . It remains to give a construction for odd with (since ). To that end, we modify the construction for by adding to the previous set. This is a valid set as can be added to each constructed expression, and can be expressed as follows: take the numbers and all the numbers from the remaining sets .
Final answer
k+4

Techniques

Coloring schemes, extremal argumentsLinear and quadratic inequalities