Browse · MathNet
PrintIMO Team Selection Contest
Estonia number theory
Problem
Prove that if and are positive integers such that , then the binomial coefficient is divisible by at least two different primes.
Solution
Assume w.l.o.g. that (if , then interchange the roles of and ). Let be an arbitrary prime number. Consider the numbers that remain into the numerator of the expression after reducing all factors by the highest power of by which they are divisible. Suppose that some two of the factors resulting after this step are equal. Then the corresponding initial factors are of the form and , where . But then , which contradicts the assumption . Hence the new factors are pairwise different. As , the numerator initially contains at least two consecutive numbers, at least one of which is not divisible by . This number does not change in the process described above. By the assumption , this number is greater than . Consequently, the product remaining in the numerator after elimination of powers of is greater than the denominator . This means that the powers of in the original numerator cannot be completely cancelled out with the denominator. So the canonical representation of cannot consist of a power of only.
---
Alternative solution.
Suppose that for some and , where is a prime number and is some positive integer. Let be a number in , in the canonical representation of which the exponent of is the largest. Then the exponent of in the canonical representation of coincides with that in the canonical representation of , respectively. Similarly, the exponent of in the canonical representation of coincides with that in the canonical representation of , respectively. Consequently, the exponent of in the canonical representation of the product equals to that in the canonical representation of the product . Since is clearly an integer, the exponent of in the canonical representation of does not exceed that in the canonical representation of . Hence, the exponent of in the canonical representation of does not exceed that in the canonical representation of . As the assumptions of the problem imply , this leads to a contradiction.
---
Alternative solution.
Suppose that for some and , where is a prime number and is some positive integer. Let be a number in , in the canonical representation of which the exponent of is the largest. Then the exponent of in the canonical representation of coincides with that in the canonical representation of , respectively. Similarly, the exponent of in the canonical representation of coincides with that in the canonical representation of , respectively. Consequently, the exponent of in the canonical representation of the product equals to that in the canonical representation of the product . Since is clearly an integer, the exponent of in the canonical representation of does not exceed that in the canonical representation of . Hence, the exponent of in the canonical representation of does not exceed that in the canonical representation of . As the assumptions of the problem imply , this leads to a contradiction.
Techniques
Prime numbersFactorization techniques