Browse · MathNet
Print30th Turkish Mathematical Olympiad
Turkey algebra
Problem
Find all real numbers for which there are different real numbers such that
Solution
Answer: and .
Letting , one sees that are the roots of the polynomial . Therefore, Vieta's theorem implies , thus and . Consequently the polynomial has three distinct real roots. Moreover, the denominators appearing in the problem statement must be nonzero, hence the roots of are nonzero. On the other hand, the converse statement also holds: if the polynomial has three distinct nonzero real roots, the equalities
in the problem statement are satisfied by these roots . Now for , one would have for positive , thus the polynomial would have no positive root, so it could not have three real roots. Similarly for , there would be no negative root and there could not be three real roots. Moreover for and , the polynomial would have a double root of and , respectively. Finally for , one of the roots of would be 0. Outside all these cases, one has or . Indeed for , one has and , hence there is a root in each of the intervals , and . Similarly for , there is a root in each of the intervals , and .
Letting , one sees that are the roots of the polynomial . Therefore, Vieta's theorem implies , thus and . Consequently the polynomial has three distinct real roots. Moreover, the denominators appearing in the problem statement must be nonzero, hence the roots of are nonzero. On the other hand, the converse statement also holds: if the polynomial has three distinct nonzero real roots, the equalities
in the problem statement are satisfied by these roots . Now for , one would have for positive , thus the polynomial would have no positive root, so it could not have three real roots. Similarly for , there would be no negative root and there could not be three real roots. Moreover for and , the polynomial would have a double root of and , respectively. Finally for , one of the roots of would be 0. Outside all these cases, one has or . Indeed for , one has and , hence there is a root in each of the intervals , and . Similarly for , there is a root in each of the intervals , and .
Final answer
-2 < a < 0 or 0 < a < 2
Techniques
Vieta's formulasIntermediate Value Theorem