Browse · MathNet
PrintEstonian Math Competitions
Estonia number theory
Problem
Find all polynomials with integral coefficients and the following property: for any pair of positive integers, implies .
Solution
Answer: All polynomials of the form where is a non-negative integer.
Firstly, we show that all prime divisors of are divisors of . Suppose that there is a prime number dividing but not dividing . Obviously ; but then while , contradicting the assumption.
Next we show that only polynomials of the form where satisfy the conditions of the problem. We proceed by induction on the degree of . If is a constant polynomial then the constant must be coprime with itself in order to satisfy the conditions of the problem. This is possible only if . Assume now that is a non-constant polynomial of degree . Then for infinitely many prime numbers . In each such case, namely must divide . Hence the constant term of must be divisible by . As the constant term does not depend on , it must be divisible by infinitely many prime numbers. Hence the constant term equals 0, i.e., where is a polynomial with integral coefficients. The polynomial satisfies the conditions of the problem, because for coprime and would imply , contradicting the choice of . By the induction hypothesis, . Thus .
On the other hand, all such polynomials satisfy the condition of the problem as implies .
---
Alternative solution.
As in Solution 1, we show that all prime divisors of are divisors of . Letting be any prime number, we conclude that for some natural number . Let the degree of be . Then for every where is a large enough integer. Thus for infinitely many prime numbers , there exists a natural number not exceeding such that . As there are finitely many such natural numbers, one can fix such that either for infinitely many primes or for infinitely many primes . This implies that either or (as a matter of fact, ). All such polynomials satisfy the conditions of the problem as implies .
Firstly, we show that all prime divisors of are divisors of . Suppose that there is a prime number dividing but not dividing . Obviously ; but then while , contradicting the assumption.
Next we show that only polynomials of the form where satisfy the conditions of the problem. We proceed by induction on the degree of . If is a constant polynomial then the constant must be coprime with itself in order to satisfy the conditions of the problem. This is possible only if . Assume now that is a non-constant polynomial of degree . Then for infinitely many prime numbers . In each such case, namely must divide . Hence the constant term of must be divisible by . As the constant term does not depend on , it must be divisible by infinitely many prime numbers. Hence the constant term equals 0, i.e., where is a polynomial with integral coefficients. The polynomial satisfies the conditions of the problem, because for coprime and would imply , contradicting the choice of . By the induction hypothesis, . Thus .
On the other hand, all such polynomials satisfy the condition of the problem as implies .
---
Alternative solution.
As in Solution 1, we show that all prime divisors of are divisors of . Letting be any prime number, we conclude that for some natural number . Let the degree of be . Then for every where is a large enough integer. Thus for infinitely many prime numbers , there exists a natural number not exceeding such that . As there are finitely many such natural numbers, one can fix such that either for infinitely many primes or for infinitely many primes . This implies that either or (as a matter of fact, ). All such polynomials satisfy the conditions of the problem as implies .
Final answer
All polynomials P(x) = ± x^l for non-negative integers l.
Techniques
Greatest common divisors (gcd)Prime numbersPolynomials mod pPolynomials