Browse · MathNet
PrintBulgarian National Mathematical Olympiad
Bulgaria counting and probability
Problem
One hundred and one of the squares of an table are colored blue. It is known that there exists a unique way to cut the table to rectangles along boundaries of its squares with the following property: every rectangle contains exactly one blue square. Find the smallest possible .
Solution
Answer: 101. We shall prove the following more general assertion.
Lemma. Some of the squares of a table are colored blue. A partition of into rectangles of integer sides is called good if every rectangle contains exactly one blue square. Then possesses a unique good partition if and only if the blue squares form a rectangle.
Proof. It is easy to see that if the blue squares form a rectangle, there is only one good partition (there are unique choices for the angle squares of the blue rectangle, then for the remaining boundary squares and finally for the inner squares).
We now consider the other direction. Let us denote the unique good partition of by . We call dividing any (vertical or horizontal) line which cuts the table into two rectangles each of them containing at least one blue square.
We first prove that every sub-rectangle which contains at least one blue square possesses good partition. We go by induction on the number of the blue squares in . The assertion is obvious for a single blue square. For more blue squares we cut into two smaller rectangles and , each of them containing blue square(s) and apply the induction hypothesis.
It follows from the above that every dividing line determines good partition which includes the line . Therefore every dividing line is included in the partition .
Let be all vertical dividing lines (from left to right end) and are all horizontal dividing lines (from bottom to upper end). Then these lines divide the table into rectangles, each of them containing at most one blue square. Therefore does not include any lines different from these and, in fact, every rectangle contains exactly one blue square.
Let be the rightmost vertical line such that there are no blue squares on its left side, is the leftmost vertical line such that there are no blue squares on its right side, and and are defined analogously. It is clear that the distance between and equals 1 for every and, analogously, the distance between and equals 1 for every (otherwise further dividing lines could be added). Therefore the set of the blue squares coincides with the rectangle defined from the lines and , which completes the proof of the lemma.
In our problem, we see that the 101 blue squares form a rectangle. Moreover, one of the sides of this rectangle must be 1, and the other one, equal to 101, must be equal to .
Lemma. Some of the squares of a table are colored blue. A partition of into rectangles of integer sides is called good if every rectangle contains exactly one blue square. Then possesses a unique good partition if and only if the blue squares form a rectangle.
Proof. It is easy to see that if the blue squares form a rectangle, there is only one good partition (there are unique choices for the angle squares of the blue rectangle, then for the remaining boundary squares and finally for the inner squares).
We now consider the other direction. Let us denote the unique good partition of by . We call dividing any (vertical or horizontal) line which cuts the table into two rectangles each of them containing at least one blue square.
We first prove that every sub-rectangle which contains at least one blue square possesses good partition. We go by induction on the number of the blue squares in . The assertion is obvious for a single blue square. For more blue squares we cut into two smaller rectangles and , each of them containing blue square(s) and apply the induction hypothesis.
It follows from the above that every dividing line determines good partition which includes the line . Therefore every dividing line is included in the partition .
Let be all vertical dividing lines (from left to right end) and are all horizontal dividing lines (from bottom to upper end). Then these lines divide the table into rectangles, each of them containing at most one blue square. Therefore does not include any lines different from these and, in fact, every rectangle contains exactly one blue square.
Let be the rightmost vertical line such that there are no blue squares on its left side, is the leftmost vertical line such that there are no blue squares on its right side, and and are defined analogously. It is clear that the distance between and equals 1 for every and, analogously, the distance between and equals 1 for every (otherwise further dividing lines could be added). Therefore the set of the blue squares coincides with the rectangle defined from the lines and , which completes the proof of the lemma.
In our problem, we see that the 101 blue squares form a rectangle. Moreover, one of the sides of this rectangle must be 1, and the other one, equal to 101, must be equal to .
Final answer
101
Techniques
Coloring schemes, extremal argumentsInduction / smoothing