Browse · MathNet
PrintXIX OBM
Brazil algebra
Problem
Let be the set of real numbers. Show that there are no functions such that and for all . Let be the set of all real numbers greater than . Show that there are functions satisfying the condition above.
Solution
First of all, since and is injective, is injective. Indeed, . Plugging in , we obtain . If , consider (i.e., the roots of ): , and , so , which contradicts the fact that is injective. So in this case there are no such functions .
If , consider and . Applying these two identities times we obtain and . In particular, and . Extend these identities for all real. We have and . This means that and . For the sake of simplicity, write all equations in base : and . Now substitute in the original equations: It is clear that both and are well defined in and that it's possible to choose and (for example, and ), so such functions do exist.
If , consider and . Applying these two identities times we obtain and . In particular, and . Extend these identities for all real. We have and . This means that and . For the sake of simplicity, write all equations in base : and . Now substitute in the original equations: It is clear that both and are well defined in and that it's possible to choose and (for example, and ), so such functions do exist.
Techniques
Injectivity / surjectivityExistential quantifiers