Browse · MathNet
PrintRomanian Master of Mathematics
Romania number theory
Problem
Fix integers and greater than . For any positive integer , let be the (non-negative) remainder leaves upon division by . Assume that there exists a positive integer such that for all integers . Prove that divides .
Solution
Arguing indirectly, assume that , so for all . Let .
We now prove that for all . Indeed, as , it follows that and . Therefore, is the remainder leaves upon division by , i.e., is the smallest non-negative integer such that . This implies , as .
To complete the solution, note that , so for all . On the other hand, for sufficiently large. This is a contradiction.
---
Alternative solution.
The conclusion holds under the much less restrictive condition for all integers . The argument hinges on the lemma below:
Lemma. Consider two integers . If does not divide , then for infinitely many positive integers ; as usual, denotes the fractional part of the real number .
Proof. For every positive integer , write and and note that is an integer.
Suppose now, if possible, that for all . Consider any such and note that , as does not divide , so . Hence the integer , so .
Consequently, for all . As , it then follows that for all large enough , contradicting the fact that whatever . This establishes the lemma.
Back to the problem, suppose does not divide . Then ; otherwise which is impossible. Note that for all large enough . The lemma then implies for some large enough which is clearly a contradiction.
We now prove that for all . Indeed, as , it follows that and . Therefore, is the remainder leaves upon division by , i.e., is the smallest non-negative integer such that . This implies , as .
To complete the solution, note that , so for all . On the other hand, for sufficiently large. This is a contradiction.
---
Alternative solution.
The conclusion holds under the much less restrictive condition for all integers . The argument hinges on the lemma below:
Lemma. Consider two integers . If does not divide , then for infinitely many positive integers ; as usual, denotes the fractional part of the real number .
Proof. For every positive integer , write and and note that is an integer.
Suppose now, if possible, that for all . Consider any such and note that , as does not divide , so . Hence the integer , so .
Consequently, for all . As , it then follows that for all large enough , contradicting the fact that whatever . This establishes the lemma.
Back to the problem, suppose does not divide . Then ; otherwise which is impossible. Note that for all large enough . The lemma then implies for some large enough which is clearly a contradiction.
Techniques
Factorization techniquesModular ArithmeticFloors and ceilings