Browse · MathNet
PrintThe DANUBE Mathematical Competition
Romania counting and probability
Problem
On a line, there are 51 positive integers whose sum is 100. Prove that, for all positive integers , , one can find either a succession of numbers on the line whose sum is , or a succession of numbers whose sum is .
Solution
Let be the 51 numbers with . On a circle of total length 100 we place 100 points such that the length of the arc between any two neighboring points (of these 100) is equal to 1. We fix one of these points and denote it by . Then, we mark on the circle points , in this order, such that the length of each arc is for all . Clearly, the length of the arc will be .
We color the points with blue, and the other 49 points with red. We prove that for all we can find two blue points, and , such that the lengths of the two arcs determined by these two points are and . It is sufficient to prove this statement for .
For we have 51 blue points, so there must be a pair of blue points that are diametrically opposed. For , consider for each blue point the points such that the length of the arc is . There are two such points for each point . If any of these points is blue, we have found an arc of length . Assume all these points are red; each of these points has been considered at most twice, but each blue point uses two red ones. Thus, 51 blue points require 51 red ones, but only 49 are available. We conclude that our assumption was false, therefore an arc of length must exist.
Now we cut the circle at and turn it into a line segment. For all , we might have thus cut one of the arcs , either the one of length or the one of length , but not both. Thus, for all , either a line segment of length , or one of length , must exist.
We color the points with blue, and the other 49 points with red. We prove that for all we can find two blue points, and , such that the lengths of the two arcs determined by these two points are and . It is sufficient to prove this statement for .
For we have 51 blue points, so there must be a pair of blue points that are diametrically opposed. For , consider for each blue point the points such that the length of the arc is . There are two such points for each point . If any of these points is blue, we have found an arc of length . Assume all these points are red; each of these points has been considered at most twice, but each blue point uses two red ones. Thus, 51 blue points require 51 red ones, but only 49 are available. We conclude that our assumption was false, therefore an arc of length must exist.
Now we cut the circle at and turn it into a line segment. For all , we might have thus cut one of the arcs , either the one of length or the one of length , but not both. Thus, for all , either a line segment of length , or one of length , must exist.
Techniques
Pigeonhole principleColoring schemes, extremal argumentsConstructions and loci