Browse · MathNet
PrintSAUDI ARABIAN MATHEMATICAL COMPETITIONS
Saudi Arabia counting and probability
Problem
For integer , consider cube polynomials such that each polynomial has 3 distinct real roots. Denote as the set of roots of the following equation It is also known that for each , has 5 distinct real roots.
1. Prove that if for each , there is exactly one such that then .
2. Prove that if then .
1. Prove that if for each , there is exactly one such that then .
2. Prove that if then .
Solution
1) For , denote as the set of roots of then since the given condition, we can see that and for all then .
Suppose that and . Denote as the number of sets that contain then we will count in which , , and , .
- Choose first, we have . - Choose first, we have .
Then . This argument can be applied the same for so for all , there are exactly sets that contain .
Then by counting such that , we have
By counting such that , we have
By solving this system of equations, we have .
2) For , denote and by pigeonhole principle, there is some element of that appears in at least 3 sets among . Without loss of generality, we can suppose that . We shall prove that for all . If there is some index with then we can write for .
It is clear to check that for all and for since all sets contain . This implies that , which is a contradiction.
Hence, all sets share one common element . This means
In general, we can state this problem as follows: For integers , we consider and subsets of such that for . Suppose that for all .
1. If for each , there is exactly 1 subset such that then . 2. If then there is exactly 1 element that appears in all sets and .
The way to solve this problem is the same as the solution for the original problem.
Suppose that and . Denote as the number of sets that contain then we will count in which , , and , .
- Choose first, we have . - Choose first, we have .
Then . This argument can be applied the same for so for all , there are exactly sets that contain .
Then by counting such that , we have
By counting such that , we have
By solving this system of equations, we have .
2) For , denote and by pigeonhole principle, there is some element of that appears in at least 3 sets among . Without loss of generality, we can suppose that . We shall prove that for all . If there is some index with then we can write for .
It is clear to check that for all and for since all sets contain . This implies that , which is a contradiction.
Hence, all sets share one common element . This means
In general, we can state this problem as follows: For integers , we consider and subsets of such that for . Suppose that for all .
1. If for each , there is exactly 1 subset such that then . 2. If then there is exactly 1 element that appears in all sets and .
The way to solve this problem is the same as the solution for the original problem.
Final answer
Under the uniqueness condition, n = 7. If n > 7, then |S| = 2n + 1.
Techniques
Counting two waysPigeonhole principleColoring schemes, extremal argumentsPolynomials