Browse · MathNet
PrintSeventeenth ROMANIAN MASTER OF MATHEMATICS
Romania number theory
Problem
Consider a sequence of integers such that and is a square for all positive integers . Is it possible that two terms of such a sequence be equal?
Solution
The answer is in the negative. Notice first that, if , then ; since is a perfect square, we should have or , so in particular . As , we conclude that all terms of the sequence are greater than 1.
Denote the largest prime divisor of an integer by . We will show that for all , which yields the desired result. To this end, usage is made of the lemma below.
Lemma: For any prime , each prime divisor of is greater than .
Proof. Let be a prime factor of ; then is odd. The multiplicative order of modulo divides and is larger than , so . On the other hand, by Fermat's little theorem, , so and the lemma follows.
Choose now any positive integer , and denote, for convenience, and . Let ; then . Since , this number is not a square, so there exists a prime such that is odd. By the Lemma, , so in particular . Therefore, by the Lifting Exponent Lemma, so is odd as well. Since is a perfect square, we should then have , so , as desired.
Denote the largest prime divisor of an integer by . We will show that for all , which yields the desired result. To this end, usage is made of the lemma below.
Lemma: For any prime , each prime divisor of is greater than .
Proof. Let be a prime factor of ; then is odd. The multiplicative order of modulo divides and is larger than , so . On the other hand, by Fermat's little theorem, , so and the lemma follows.
Choose now any positive integer , and denote, for convenience, and . Let ; then . Since , this number is not a square, so there exists a prime such that is odd. By the Lemma, , so in particular . Therefore, by the Lifting Exponent Lemma, so is odd as well. Since is a perfect square, we should then have , so , as desired.
Final answer
No
Techniques
Prime numbersFermat / Euler / Wilson theoremsMultiplicative order