Browse · MathNet
PrintBaltic Way 2023 Shortlist
Baltic Way 2023 algebra
Problem
Denote a set of equations in the real numbers with variables Flensburgian if there exists an such that every solution of the set of equations where all the variables are pairwise different, satisfies for all . Determine for which positive integer , the following set of two equations in the three real variables is Flensburgian.
Solution
The set of equations given in the problem statement is Flensburgian precisely when is even or .
To see that it is not Flensburgian when is odd, notice that if satisfies the set of equations then so does . Hence, if there exists a single solution to the set of equations where all the variables are different then the set of equations cannot be Flensburgian. This is in fact the case, e.g., consider .
If from the first equation we know . But then from the second equation it follows . Hence, there cannot be any solution with pairwise different variables . Therefore, the set of equations is Flensburgian for .
The rest of the solution is dedicated to prove that the set of equations is indeed Flensburgian when is even.
The first equation yields , since when is even. The inequality is strict whenever and the case implies , i.e. , which we can disregard. Substituting the relation into the second equation yields since we can disregard and is even. Since is odd, the polynomial is strictly increasing, implying that . Hence, when is even, all solutions of the set of equations where are pairwise different satisfy and .
To see that it is not Flensburgian when is odd, notice that if satisfies the set of equations then so does . Hence, if there exists a single solution to the set of equations where all the variables are different then the set of equations cannot be Flensburgian. This is in fact the case, e.g., consider .
If from the first equation we know . But then from the second equation it follows . Hence, there cannot be any solution with pairwise different variables . Therefore, the set of equations is Flensburgian for .
The rest of the solution is dedicated to prove that the set of equations is indeed Flensburgian when is even.
The first equation yields , since when is even. The inequality is strict whenever and the case implies , i.e. , which we can disregard. Substituting the relation into the second equation yields since we can disregard and is even. Since is odd, the polynomial is strictly increasing, implying that . Hence, when is even, all solutions of the set of equations where are pairwise different satisfy and .
Final answer
n = 1 or n is even
Techniques
PolynomialsEquations and Inequalities