Browse · MathNet
PrintMongolian Mathematical Olympiad
Mongolia number theory
Problem
Show that is not a perfect square for any positive integer .
Solution
Suppose, for contradiction, that there exists a positive integer such that is a perfect square.
Let for some integer .
Consider : , which is not a perfect square.
Consider : , which is not a perfect square.
Consider : , which is not a perfect square.
Now, for , note that , so is between and .
Let be such that .
Then is close to , so .
But implies .
So .
Let for some integer (since must be close to ).
Then:
So:
But grows much slower than for large , unless is very small.
Try :
But for , (since for ).
Try :
But this is negative for .
Therefore, there is no integer such that for .
Thus, is never a perfect square for any positive integer .
Let for some integer .
Consider : , which is not a perfect square.
Consider : , which is not a perfect square.
Consider : , which is not a perfect square.
Now, for , note that , so is between and .
Let be such that .
Then is close to , so .
But implies .
So .
Let for some integer (since must be close to ).
Then:
So:
But grows much slower than for large , unless is very small.
Try :
But for , (since for ).
Try :
But this is negative for .
Therefore, there is no integer such that for .
Thus, is never a perfect square for any positive integer .
Techniques
Techniques: modulo, size analysis, order analysis, inequalities