Browse · MathNet
PrintIMO Team Selection Test 2
Netherlands algebra
Problem
Let be a positive integer. For a real , assume that are all squares of positive integers. Prove that is also the square of a positive integer.
Here is the greatest integer smaller than or equal to .
Here is the greatest integer smaller than or equal to .
Solution
We first prove the statement for . Write , with an integer and . Suppose and are squares. Then we have , from which it follows that . Hence, is squeezed between two consecutive squares. However, is a square, hence the only possibility is that . We conclude that .
Completely analogously, we also get that and hence . We conclude that .
Moreover, we have that . Now suppose that , i.e. which gives a contradiction. Hence, , which yields that . This is also a square, hence must be a square itself. We see that is a square.
Now we will finish the proof with induction to . The induction basis has just been proved. Now let and suppose that the statement is proved for . Consider a real number with the property that are all squares. In particular, , and are all squares. We can now apply the case on (which is a real number greater than or equal to 1) and find that is also a square. Now we know that are all squares and using the induction hypothesis, we obtain that is a square as well. This completes the proof by induction.
Completely analogously, we also get that and hence . We conclude that .
Moreover, we have that . Now suppose that , i.e. which gives a contradiction. Hence, , which yields that . This is also a square, hence must be a square itself. We see that is a square.
Now we will finish the proof with induction to . The induction basis has just been proved. Now let and suppose that the statement is proved for . Consider a real number with the property that are all squares. In particular, , and are all squares. We can now apply the case on (which is a real number greater than or equal to 1) and find that is also a square. Now we know that are all squares and using the induction hypothesis, we obtain that is a square as well. This completes the proof by induction.
Techniques
Floors and ceilingsIntegersInduction / smoothing