Skip to main content
OlympiadHQ

Browse · MATH

Print

jmc

geometry senior

Problem

Two identical rectangular crates are packed with cylindrical pipes, using different methods. Each pipe has diameter 10 cm. A side view of the first four rows of each of the two different methods of packing is shown below.

problem


problem


After the crates have been packed with 200 pipes each, what is the positive difference in the total heights (in cm) of the two packings?
Solution
In Crate A, we have 20 rows of 10 pipes packed directly on top of each other. So the height of the packing is 20 times the diameter of a single pipe, or 200 cm. In Crate B, draw a horizontal line through the centers of the 9 or 10 pipes in each row. By symmetry, the distance between each consecutive pair of these 21 lines will be the same, say equal to . There will be 20 such distances.



The distance of the bottom line from the bottom of the crate is equal to the radius of a pipe, and the distance of the top line from the top of the top row is also equal to the radius of a pipe. Thus, the total height of the packing in Crate B is equal to cm.

Next, we find . If we extract three pairwise touching pipes from two consecutive rows, their centers form an equilateral triangle with side length equal to the diameter of each pipe, so is equal to the height of this equilateral triangle, i.e. cm. Therefore, the total height of this packing is cm, which is approximately 183.2 cm.

Therefore, the difference in the total heights of the two packings is cm, or about 16.8 cm, with the packing in Crate A being the higher one.
Final answer
190-100\sqrt{3}