Browse · MathNet
PrintSELECTION EXAMINATION
Greece counting and probability
Problem
In a School formed groups each contained students. Every pair of groups had exactly one common student. Prove that:
a. There exists a student belonging at least to groups.
b. There exists a student belonging to all groups.
a. There exists a student belonging at least to groups.
b. There exists a student belonging to all groups.
Solution
a. We consider an arbitrary group . Each of the rest groups has exactly one student belonging to . Since , from the pigeonhole's rule we conclude that there exists one student who belongs at least to other groups. Hence belongs at least to groups, say .
b. We will prove that belongs to all groups. In fact, let . Then the group has exactly one common student with the groups . Since has students, then there will exist two groups, say having the same common student with the group , say . However, in this case the groups will have two common students and , absurd.
Therefore belongs to all groups.
b. We will prove that belongs to all groups. In fact, let . Then the group has exactly one common student with the groups . Since has students, then there will exist two groups, say having the same common student with the group , say . However, in this case the groups will have two common students and , absurd.
Therefore belongs to all groups.
Techniques
Pigeonhole principle