Skip to main content
OlympiadHQ

Browse · MathNet

Print

First selection test for IMO 2007, Vietnam

Bulgaria 2007 number theory

Problem

Prove that there are no distinct positive integers and such that
Solution
Assume, for the sake of contradiction, that there exist distinct positive integers and such that Without loss of generality, suppose .

Then, Let us estimate the size of both sides for large and .

Note that for , is divisible by , and is divisible by .

Let us consider the case . Then is divisible by all numbers up to , in particular by , so is divisible by . But is divisible by , so is divisible by . But , and for , (since factorial grows faster than any fixed power). Therefore, , so the only way divides is if , i.e., , which contradicts the assumption that and are distinct.

Therefore, .

Now, can only take finitely many values: . For each such , is a positive integer. Let us check for small values of :

If : But for , is much larger than . For , grows much faster than only for very large , but for small , is much larger than . So there is no solution for .

If : But for , is much larger than . For , is much larger than . So there is no solution for .

Similarly, for , is always much larger than for .

Therefore, there are no solutions in positive integers and with .

Thus, there are no distinct positive integers and such that

Techniques

Techniques: modulo, size analysis, order analysis, inequalitiesFactorization techniques