Skip to main content
OlympiadHQ

Browse · MathNet

Print

China Mathematical Olympiad

China number theory

Problem

Let be a given integer and be an infinite set of positive integers satisfying: for any prime , there exist infinitely many elements of not divisible by . Prove that for any integer , , there exists a finite subset of whose sum of elements, say , satisfies and .
Solution
Suppose a prime satisfies . Then from the given conditions, there exists an infinite subset of such that is coprime to every element in . By the pigeonhole principle, there is an infinite subset of , such that , for each element , where is a positive integer and . Since , we have . By the Chinese Remainder Theorem, we know that have infinitely many solutions. Among them we take one as . Next define as the set of the first elements in , and as the sum of all elements in . Then we have . By ① we have

Suppose that , and for every () select a finite subset of , where , such that , the sum of all the elements in , satisfies Let , whose sum of elements then satisfies . According to ②, we have (), and . So is the required subset, and the proof is complete.

Solution 2:

Divide every element in by , and let the remainders which occur infinitely be (in order) . We claim that Otherwise, assume that . Then , since . By the given conditions we know that there exist infinitely many elements of not divisible by . But by the definition of , the number of such elements are finite. Then by contradiction, ③ holds. Consequently, there are , satisfying . Choose a suitable positive integer such that . Then We select in order elements from such that the remainders by are (). The set of all these elements is acquired.

Techniques

Chinese remainder theoremInverses mod nGreatest common divisors (gcd)Pigeonhole principle