Skip to main content
OlympiadHQ

Browse · MathNet

Print

Belarus2022

Belarus 2022 number theory

Problem

Let be the sequence of positive integers. For each number from to the following collection was found: where all indices are taken modulo , i.e. if then . It turned out that all these collections consist of the same pairwise distinct numbers maybe in different ordering. Find out if can be equal to a) ; b) .
Solution
Let us prove the following Statement: for some positive integer . Proof: Let be the largest of the greatest common divisors found. Then the equality is equivalent to the fact that each of the numbers and is a multiple of . Let be all indexes of numbers in the given sequence that are multiples of , written in ascending order. Note that each pair of indices yields twice: for and for . Therefore will occur as the greatest common divisor exactly times and by assumption this number is . Thus . The assertion is proved.

b) The equation is equivalent to . The left side of this equation increases for while and , therefore this equation doesn't have a positive integer solutions. According to the proven statement, the answer at this item is: "no".

a) Note that , i.e. satisfies the statement for . It is easy to construct the sequence from the proof of this statement, for example . Let us set then choose different primes and for each from to multiply by the numbers . It is easy to see that for each from to the set of greatest common divisors from the problem statement coincides with the set .
Final answer
a) yes; b) no

Techniques

Greatest common divisors (gcd)Counting two ways