Browse · MathNet
PrintChina Girls' Mathematical Olympiad
China counting and probability
Problem
Eight persons join a party.
(1) If there exist three persons who know each other in any group of five, prove that we can find that four persons know each other.
(2) If there exist three persons in a group of six who know each other in a cyclical manner, can we find four persons who know each other in a cyclical manner?
(1) If there exist three persons who know each other in any group of five, prove that we can find that four persons know each other.
(2) If there exist three persons in a group of six who know each other in a cyclical manner, can we find four persons who know each other in a cyclical manner?
Solution
(1) By means of graph theory, use vertices to denote persons. If two persons know each other, we connect them with an edge. With the given condition, there will be a triangle in every induced subgraph with five vertices, while every triangle in the graph belongs to different induced subgraphs with five vertices. We know that there are edges in total in these triangles, while every edge is computed ten times repeatedly.
Thus every vertex is incident with at least edges. So there exists one vertex that is incident with at least five edges.
Suppose the vertex is adjacent with five vertices , , , , . By the condition, there exists one triangle in five vertices. Without loss of generality, let denote the triangle. So there exists one edge between any two vertices in the four vertices , , , . So the corresponding four persons of the four vertices know each other.
(2) If there exist three persons (in a group of six) who know one another in a cyclical manner, there may not exist four persons who know each other.
For example, let vertices denote persons. If two persons know each other, we join them with an edge. Consider the regular octagon, we link up the shortest diagonals, as desired.
Thus every vertex is incident with at least edges. So there exists one vertex that is incident with at least five edges.
Suppose the vertex is adjacent with five vertices , , , , . By the condition, there exists one triangle in five vertices. Without loss of generality, let denote the triangle. So there exists one edge between any two vertices in the four vertices , , , . So the corresponding four persons of the four vertices know each other.
(2) If there exist three persons (in a group of six) who know one another in a cyclical manner, there may not exist four persons who know each other.
For example, let vertices denote persons. If two persons know each other, we join them with an edge. Consider the regular octagon, we link up the shortest diagonals, as desired.
Final answer
Part (1): Yes, there exists a group of four mutual acquaintances. Part (2): No.
Techniques
Counting two waysColoring schemes, extremal arguments