Skip to main content
OlympiadHQ

Browse · MathNet

Print

European Mathematical Cup

North Macedonia number theory

Problem

is a set containing three positive integers. Prove that we can find a set , such that for all odd positive integers we have
Solution
Let . If , the problem statement will be fulfilled no matter how we choose so from now on, without loss of generality, we consider . Since and are both odd, we have that is even and we get where .

Now if one of is even, is even. If both are odd, then is again even since and are even in that case. This shows that we only need to consider divisibility by .

If contains at least one element divisible by , we can put it in and that will give us the solution easily.

Now we consider the case when none of the elements in is divisible by . If some two numbers in give the same remainder modulo , we can choose them and then will be divisible by which solves the problem.

Now we consider the case when all remainders modulo in are different. Take a look at the pairs and . Since we have three different remainders modulo , by pigeonhole principle one of these pairs has to be completely in (when elements are considered modulo ). Then if we pick the numbers from that correspond to those two remainders we get that is divisible by so the problem statement is fulfilled again. This completes the proof.

Techniques

Factorization techniquesPigeonhole principle