Browse · MathNet
PrintRomanian Master of Mathematics
Romania counting and probability
Problem
In a country there are airports and air companies operating return flights. Each company operates an odd number of flights forming a closed route. Prove that a traveller can complete a closed route consisting of an odd number of flights operated by pairwise distinct companies.
Solution
In graph-theoretic setting, the statement reads: Consider a collection of odd cycles, not necessarily distinct, all on the same vertex set of size . Prove that at most one edge can be chosen from each of these cycles to form a collection that contains the edges of an odd cycle. Call a set of edges rainbow if it is formed by choosing at most one edge from each cycle. We have to prove that there exists a rainbow cycle of odd length. Begin by choosing a maximal rainbow forest , that is, an acyclic rainbow set of edges. Since is acyclic, its size is less than , so there is a cycle in the collection no edge of which lies in . The forest contains every vertex of , for otherwise an edge of incident with a vertex outside could be added to to form a larger rainbow forest, contradicting maximality. Moreover, no edge of joins different components of , for one such could again be added to to contradict maximality. Consequently, the vertices of all lie in some component of , a tree . As such, is bipartite, that is, its vertices split into two disjoint parts, and all edges are between the two. Since is an odd cycle, it has an edge whose endpoints both lie in the same part. This edge then completes an odd rainbow cycle.
Techniques
Graph TheoryColoring schemes, extremal arguments