Skip to main content
OlympiadHQ

Browse · MathNet

Print

Ireland_2017

Ireland 2017 counting and probability

Problem

There are some boys and some girls at a party. A set of boys is said to be sociable if every girl at the party knows at least one boy in that set, and similarly a set of girls is said to be sociable if every boy at the party knows at least one girl in that set. Suppose that the number of sociable sets of boys is odd. Prove that the number of sociable sets of girls is also odd.

NOTE: Acquaintance is mutual.
Solution
We say that a set of boys is separated from a set of girls if no boy in knows any girl in . Similarly, a set of girls is separated from a set of boys if no girl in knows any boy in . Since acquaintance is mutual, separation is symmetric: is separated from if and only if is separated from .

Let denote the number of ordered pairs such that is a subset of boys, is a subset of girls, and is separated from .

For any set of boys, denote by the set of girls who are not acquainted with any boy in . Then is separated from exactly sets of girls, and so Exactly those terms in the sum are odd for which is empty, i.e., when is sociable. Therefore is congruent modulo to the number of sociable sets of boys.

A similar argument shows that is congruent modulo to the number of sociable sets of girls. Therefore, if the number of sociable sets of boys is odd, then the number of sociable sets of girls is also odd.

Techniques

Counting two ways