Browse · MathNet
PrintNMO Selection Tests for the Junior Balkan Mathematical Olympiad
Romania counting and probability
Problem
Let be an integer. Consider distinct points in the plane, each coloured either white or black. For each positive integer , a -move consists in selecting points and reversing their colours. Find all values of for which, for any eligible and for any initial colouring, there exists a sequence of -moves that turns all points into a same colour.
Solution
The problem holds for and only for odd.
To this end, suppose even. Colour exactly one point in white and the rest in black. Choose . After performing a 2-move, the number of points of a same colour remains odd, so a monochromatic configuration is not achievable.
Suppose odd. Assume odd. Consider an initial colouring with white points and black points. Let , . Perform -moves upon the white points to reach a configuration of white and black points. Perform a -move with the white points and other black to obtain exactly white points. Therefore, one can obtain exactly or exactly white points, with only one of the numbers or being even, say .
Perform a -move with the white points to get exactly white points. After another -move with the white points, all points turn black and we are done.
Assume even. Again, consider an initial colouring with white points and black points. One of the numbers or is even, say . In , , notice that is even. From this point on, proceed as in the previous case.
To this end, suppose even. Colour exactly one point in white and the rest in black. Choose . After performing a 2-move, the number of points of a same colour remains odd, so a monochromatic configuration is not achievable.
Suppose odd. Assume odd. Consider an initial colouring with white points and black points. Let , . Perform -moves upon the white points to reach a configuration of white and black points. Perform a -move with the white points and other black to obtain exactly white points. Therefore, one can obtain exactly or exactly white points, with only one of the numbers or being even, say .
Perform a -move with the white points to get exactly white points. After another -move with the white points, all points turn black and we are done.
Assume even. Again, consider an initial colouring with white points and black points. One of the numbers or is even, say . In , , notice that is even. From this point on, proceed as in the previous case.
Final answer
All odd integers n
Techniques
Invariants / monovariantsColoring schemes, extremal arguments