Browse · MathNet
Print41st Balkan Mathematical Olympiad
number theory
Problem
Let be a fixed natural number and Are there distinct numbers and , , such that ?
Solution
For , the answer is negative. For we will show that answer is positive. In contrary, since , we see that the set is complete system of remainders modulo . Thus, Let us calculate . Denote by , and , for all . Then: Since , by induction, it follows that holds for all .
So, by using (1) and (2), we have: Since , from (3), we obtain and for , since , we get Finally, from (5), by induction, we see that for all holds and by (\cap) and (\diamond) we arrive at a contradiction.
---
Alternative solution.
Alternative Solution. Assume such and do not exist and let . Since , we see that the set is complete system of remainders modulo . Note that the numbers give four consecutive remainders modulo . Call such four consecutive remainders a block. Therefore all remainders modulo can be split into blocks. Thus, the difference of any two of the numbers is congruent to modulo . But implying , a contradiction.
So, by using (1) and (2), we have: Since , from (3), we obtain and for , since , we get Finally, from (5), by induction, we see that for all holds and by (\cap) and (\diamond) we arrive at a contradiction.
---
Alternative solution.
Alternative Solution. Assume such and do not exist and let . Since , we see that the set is complete system of remainders modulo . Note that the numbers give four consecutive remainders modulo . Call such four consecutive remainders a block. Therefore all remainders modulo can be split into blocks. Thus, the difference of any two of the numbers is congruent to modulo . But implying , a contradiction.
Final answer
No for n = 1; Yes for n > 1.
Techniques
Modular ArithmeticSums and products