Browse · MathNet
PrintArgentine National Olympiad 2015
Argentina 2015 number theory
Problem
Find all that can be represented in the form with . Here denotes the least common multiple of and .
Solution
All are representable except the powers of . Set . Take an arbitrary and let , to obtain . Hence all odd , , are representable. If is representable then so is
because implies . So each is representable if it has an odd divisor greater than . There remain the powers of , with . We show that they are not representable. This is true for since clearly for all . Suppose that with . Consider the least with this property. Observe that at least two numbers among are even. Otherwise is odd while is even. If are all even, they can be divided by to yield , which contradicts the minimality of . Hence one may assume that are even and is odd. Here . Note also that Analogously . It follows that
because implies . So each is representable if it has an odd divisor greater than . There remain the powers of , with . We show that they are not representable. This is true for since clearly for all . Suppose that with . Consider the least with this property. Observe that at least two numbers among are even. Otherwise is odd while is even. If are all even, they can be divided by to yield , which contradicts the minimality of . Hence one may assume that are even and is odd. Here . Note also that Analogously . It follows that
Final answer
All natural numbers that are not powers of 2
Techniques
Greatest common divisors (gcd)Infinite descent / root flippingTechniques: modulo, size analysis, order analysis, inequalities