Browse · MathNet
PrintSeventeenth Stars of Mathematics Competition
Romania algebra
Problem
Determine all positive integers satisfying the following condition: There exist pairwise distinct integers such that
Solution
The required integers are and . In the former case, is the unique pair of integers satisfying the conditions in the statement; and in the latter, only and fit the bill. Verification is routine.
The degree monic polynomial vanishes at each and at each . Since these numbers are pairwise distinct and , they form the root set of . Moreover, since the root set of each factor has size at most 2, and the union of these root sets has size , they must be pairwise disjoint sets of size 2 each. Recall now that is monic to write . Consequently, .
If no is zero, identification of constant terms of both sides yields . This is impossible for pairwise distinct integers unless , in which case , and . This polynomial must vanish at , so . Consequently, , as required.
If some , say, , then , so does not vanish at . Since the root set of has size 2, this forces . The polynomial equality at the end of the second paragraph now reads .
Since are all non-zero, identification of constant terms of both sides above yields . This is impossible for pairwise distinct integers unless or .
If , then , and and . Recall that the root sets of and are disjoint and both have size 2. Since and , the roots of must be and , so the other root of must be . The condition yields , and the condition then yields . Consequently, .
The other quadruple, , corresponds to the case where .
Finally, to rule out the case , we may and will assume that and . Then , , , and has the (pairwise distinct) roots and . Since , it follows that and are roots of . Notice that and , so , i. e., . This contradiction settles the case.
The degree monic polynomial vanishes at each and at each . Since these numbers are pairwise distinct and , they form the root set of . Moreover, since the root set of each factor has size at most 2, and the union of these root sets has size , they must be pairwise disjoint sets of size 2 each. Recall now that is monic to write . Consequently, .
If no is zero, identification of constant terms of both sides yields . This is impossible for pairwise distinct integers unless , in which case , and . This polynomial must vanish at , so . Consequently, , as required.
If some , say, , then , so does not vanish at . Since the root set of has size 2, this forces . The polynomial equality at the end of the second paragraph now reads .
Since are all non-zero, identification of constant terms of both sides above yields . This is impossible for pairwise distinct integers unless or .
If , then , and and . Recall that the root sets of and are disjoint and both have size 2. Since and , the roots of must be and , so the other root of must be . The condition yields , and the condition then yields . Consequently, .
The other quadruple, , corresponds to the case where .
Finally, to rule out the case , we may and will assume that and . Then , , , and has the (pairwise distinct) roots and . Since , it follows that and are roots of . Notice that and , so , i. e., . This contradiction settles the case.
Final answer
1, 2
Techniques
Polynomial operationsVieta's formulas