Browse · MathNet
PrintBelarus2022
Belarus 2022 counting and probability
Problem
Let be a positive integer. On the segment of the real line there are marked pairwise distinct segments with integer endpoints. It is known that it's impossible to choose a set of these segments such that the sum of their lengths is and their union is . (We say that the two segments are distinct if their endpoints doesn't coincide. The union of the segments is considered as the union of the sets of real numbers.) Find the maximal possible value of .
Solution
Answer: .
Each set of segments that satisfies the condition of the problem is called good. Consider a set consisting of all segments of the form , where and . This collection contains segments and it is good since even the union of all segments of the collection does not cover the point . Therefore the maximum possible value of the number is not less than .
Let us prove the following Claim: For any good collection there exists a good collection containing the same number of segments and not containing any segment of the form , .
Proof of the claim: If the set does not contain any segment of the form , then put . Otherwise among all segments of of the form , consider the segment of minimum length. Let us exclude the segment from the set and instead add the segment , which obviously was not contained in . The resulting set will also be good. Indeed if it's possible to select several segments of the total length from the new set, the union of which would coincide with the entire segment , then among them there must be a segment , but then several non-intersecting segments would cover the segment and among them there would be a segment of the form where , which is impossible due to the minimality of the number . Repeating the described procedure several times, we obtain the required set . The assertion is proved.
From the proved statement, in particular, it follows that the number of segments in an arbitrary good set is not more than , and hence the maximum possible value of the number is exactly equal to .
Each set of segments that satisfies the condition of the problem is called good. Consider a set consisting of all segments of the form , where and . This collection contains segments and it is good since even the union of all segments of the collection does not cover the point . Therefore the maximum possible value of the number is not less than .
Let us prove the following Claim: For any good collection there exists a good collection containing the same number of segments and not containing any segment of the form , .
Proof of the claim: If the set does not contain any segment of the form , then put . Otherwise among all segments of of the form , consider the segment of minimum length. Let us exclude the segment from the set and instead add the segment , which obviously was not contained in . The resulting set will also be good. Indeed if it's possible to select several segments of the total length from the new set, the union of which would coincide with the entire segment , then among them there must be a segment , but then several non-intersecting segments would cover the segment and among them there would be a segment of the form where , which is impossible due to the minimality of the number . Repeating the described procedure several times, we obtain the required set . The assertion is proved.
From the proved statement, in particular, it follows that the number of segments in an arbitrary good set is not more than , and hence the maximum possible value of the number is exactly equal to .
Final answer
n(n-1)/2
Techniques
Coloring schemes, extremal argumentsInduction / smoothing