Browse · harp
Printimc
counting and probability intermediate
Problem
Consider systems of three linear equations with unknowns , , and , where each of the coefficients is either or and the system has a solution other than . For example, one such system is with a nonzero solution of . How many such systems of equations are there? (The equations in a system need not be distinct, and two systems containing the same equations in a different order are considered different.)
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
Solution
We will use complementary counting and do casework on the equations. There are possible equations: Equation 1: Equation 2: Equation 3: Equation 4: Equation 5: Equation 6: Equation 7: Equation 8: We will continue to refer to the equations by their number on this list. total systems. Note that no two equations by themselves can force . Therefore no system with Equation 1 or with repeated equations can force . Case 1: Equation 8 () is present. Case 1a: Equation 8, and two equations from . There are ways to choose two equations from and ways to arrange each case. The number of options that force is . Case 1b: Equation 8, one equation from , and one equation from . There are ways to choose one equation from . WLOG let us choose Equation 7. Given and , we conclude that . The third equation can be either or . There are ways to arrange each case. The number of options that force is . Case 1c: Equation 8, and two equations from . There are ways to choose two equations from and ways to arrange each case. Each of these cases forces . total options. Case 2: Equation 8 is present, at least one equation from is present. Case 2a: Equations are all present. There are ways to arrange the three equations. options. Case 2b: Two equations from are present. One equation from is present. There are ways to choose two equations from . WLOG let Equations 5 and 6 be in our system: and . Any equation from will force . There are ways to arrange the equations. The number of options that force is . Case 2c: One equation from is present. Two equations from are present. There are ways to choose one equation from . WLOG let Equation 5 () be present. One of the two equations from must be Equation 4, , since it is the only equation that restricts . The last equation can be either 2 or 3. There are ways to arrange the equations. The number of options that force is . Case 3: Only equations are present. There are ways to arrange the three equations. options. We add up the cases: total systems force . Thus do not.
Final answer
B