Browse · MathNet
PrintRomanian Mathematical Olympiad
Romania algebra
Problem
Let be a finite group of order . Define the set where is the neutral element of . Let be the cardinal of . Prove that
a) , for any , where .
b) If , then is commutative.
c) If , then is non-commutative.
a) , for any , where .
b) If , then is commutative.
c) If , then is non-commutative.
Solution
a) Since is a group, it follows that . Therefore whence .
b) Let have and . Then and , . Since , it follows that . Therefore commutes with all elements of . Since , it follows the subgroup of the elements that commute with has at least elements. From Lagrange's theorem, it follows that commutes with all elements of . Therefore , the center of . It results , so .
c) Assume is commutative. If , then , so . Since is a finite set, it follows that is a subgroup of . The condition forces , so , contradiction.
b) Let have and . Then and , . Since , it follows that . Therefore commutes with all elements of . Since , it follows the subgroup of the elements that commute with has at least elements. From Lagrange's theorem, it follows that commutes with all elements of . Therefore , the center of . It results , so .
c) Assume is commutative. If , then , so . Since is a finite set, it follows that is a subgroup of . The condition forces , so , contradiction.
Techniques
Group TheoryInclusion-exclusion