Browse · MathNet
PrintUSA IMO
United States algebra
Problem
Let be positive real numbers such that Prove that at least two of the inequalities are true.
Solution
First Solution. Assume, for the sake of contradiction, that at least two of the numbers are less than . Without loss of generality, we may further assume that the first and the last are less than . Then Also, because , we have It follows that or Completing squares yields a contradiction. This proves the conclusion. To obtain equalities, that is two of the members are equal to , we must have and , that is , , . Therefore the equalities hold if and only if is one of the triples , , .
Or: Rewriting (1) as a quadratic form in yields which is impossible, because the leading coefficient is always positive and the discriminant is always nonpositive.
Second Solution. (by David Shin) Perform the substitutions , , and . It suffices to prove that at least two of the inequalities are true, where Assume, for the sake of contradiction, that at least two of the given inequalities are false. Without loss of generality, we may assume that and . Then a contradiction. Thus, our assumptions is false and at least two of the desired inequalities must be true. To obtain equalities, that is two of the numbers are equal to , we must have , or . Therefore the equalities hold if and only if , , .
Or: Rewriting (1) as a quadratic form in yields which is impossible, because the leading coefficient is always positive and the discriminant is always nonpositive.
Second Solution. (by David Shin) Perform the substitutions , , and . It suffices to prove that at least two of the inequalities are true, where Assume, for the sake of contradiction, that at least two of the given inequalities are false. Without loss of generality, we may assume that and . Then a contradiction. Thus, our assumptions is false and at least two of the desired inequalities must be true. To obtain equalities, that is two of the numbers are equal to , we must have , or . Therefore the equalities hold if and only if , , .
Techniques
Linear and quadratic inequalities