Browse · MathNet
PrintAPMO
algebra
Problem
Let denote the set of all integers. Find all polynomials with integer coefficients that satisfy the following property: For any infinite sequence of integers in which each integer in appears exactly once, there exist indices and an integer such that .
Solution
Part 1: All polynomials with satisfy the given property. Suppose , and assume without loss of generality that . Denote . It suffices to show that there exist indices and such that and .
Consider indices such that . By the pigeonhole principle, among the pairs , some two are equal, say and . We can then take and .
Part 2: All polynomials with do not satisfy the given property. Lemma: If , then for any positive integers , and , there exists an integer with such that no value in the range of falls within the interval .
Proof of Lemma: The claim is immediate when is constant or when is even since is bounded from below. Let be of odd degree greater than 1, and assume without loss of generality that . Since , and , the gap between and grows arbitrarily for large . The claim follows.
Suppose . We will inductively construct a sequence such that for any indices and any integer it holds that . Suppose that we have constructed the sequence up to , and is an integer with smallest magnitude yet to appear in the sequence. We will add two more terms to the sequence. Take . Consider all the new sums of at least two consecutive terms; each of them contains . Hence all such sums are in the interval for fixed constants . The lemma allows us to choose so that all such sums avoid the range of .
Alternate Solution for Part 1: Again, suppose , and assume without loss of generality that . Let . Then . Hence or , with the former occurring exactly when . Since , the latter can only occur finitely many times, so there exists such that for all . Let be an index with . Then we can find a sum of at least two consecutive terms ending at and congruent to .
Alternate Construction when is constant or of even degree If is of even degree, then is bounded from below or from above. In case is constant or bounded from above, then there exists a positive integer such that . Let be the sequence which is given by , , for all . Notice that for any we have . Then for the sequence defined by , clearly which is outside the range of .
Now if is bounded from below, there exists a positive integer such that . In this case, take . Then for all we have which is again outside the range of .
Consider indices such that . By the pigeonhole principle, among the pairs , some two are equal, say and . We can then take and .
Part 2: All polynomials with do not satisfy the given property. Lemma: If , then for any positive integers , and , there exists an integer with such that no value in the range of falls within the interval .
Proof of Lemma: The claim is immediate when is constant or when is even since is bounded from below. Let be of odd degree greater than 1, and assume without loss of generality that . Since , and , the gap between and grows arbitrarily for large . The claim follows.
Suppose . We will inductively construct a sequence such that for any indices and any integer it holds that . Suppose that we have constructed the sequence up to , and is an integer with smallest magnitude yet to appear in the sequence. We will add two more terms to the sequence. Take . Consider all the new sums of at least two consecutive terms; each of them contains . Hence all such sums are in the interval for fixed constants . The lemma allows us to choose so that all such sums avoid the range of .
Alternate Solution for Part 1: Again, suppose , and assume without loss of generality that . Let . Then . Hence or , with the former occurring exactly when . Since , the latter can only occur finitely many times, so there exists such that for all . Let be an index with . Then we can find a sum of at least two consecutive terms ending at and congruent to .
Alternate Construction when is constant or of even degree If is of even degree, then is bounded from below or from above. In case is constant or bounded from above, then there exists a positive integer such that . Let be the sequence which is given by , , for all . Notice that for any we have . Then for the sequence defined by , clearly which is outside the range of .
Now if is bounded from below, there exists a positive integer such that . In this case, take . Then for all we have which is again outside the range of .
Final answer
Exactly the polynomials of degree one with integer coefficients.
Techniques
PolynomialsPigeonhole principleInduction / smoothingGames / greedy algorithms