Browse · MathNet
PrintMathematica competitions in Croatia
Croatia counting and probability
Problem
A hundred quadratic envelopes, each of different size, are arranged in a way that, for every two different envelopes, the smaller one is either inside of the bigger one, or they are outside of each other. At the same time, in both of the envelopes there can be other envelopes. Two arrangements are considered different if there are two envelopes which are inside each other in one of the arrangements, while being outside of each other in the other arrangement. How many different arrangements are there such that the biggest envelope contains all the remaining envelopes? (Richard Stanley's problem set)
Solution
Denote the number of arrangements of envelopes as . Assume we are given an arrangement of envelopes. If we remove the smallest envelope, we obtain a possible arrangement of remaining envelopes. On the other hand, if we are given a possible arrangement of the remaining envelopes, we can put the smallest one directly in the biggest one, or in any of the remaining envelopes. Therefore, is exactly times larger than . We conclude that . For , the only possible arrangement is putting the smaller envelope inside the larger one, so . Therefore . For 100 envelopes, the number of different arrangements is
Final answer
99!
Techniques
Recursion, bijection