Browse · MathNet
PrintXXVIII-th Balkan Mathematical Olympiad
North Macedonia counting and probability
Problem
Let be a finite set of positive integers which has the following property: if is a member of , then so are all positive divisors of . A non-empty subset of is a good if whenever and , the ratio is a power of a prime number. A non-empty subset of is bad if whenever and , the ratio is not a power of a prime number. We agree that a singleton subset of is both good and bad. Let be the largest possible size of a good subset of . Prove that is also the smallest number of pairwise-disjoint bad subset whose union is .
Solution
Notice first that a bad subset of contains at most one element from a good one, to deduce that a partition of into bad subset has at least as many members as a maximal good subset.
Notice further the elements of a good subset of must be among the terms of a geometric sequence whose ratio is a prime: if are elements of a good subset of , then and for some primes and and some positive integers and , so for to be a power of a prime.
Next, let denote the set of all primes, let where is the exponent of the prime in the canonical decomposition of , and notice that a maximal good subset of must be of the form for some prime and some positive integer which is not divisible by . Consequently, a maximal good subset of has elements, so a partition of into bad subsets has at least members.
Finally, notice by maximality of that the sets form a partition of into bad subsets. The conclusion follows.
Notice further the elements of a good subset of must be among the terms of a geometric sequence whose ratio is a prime: if are elements of a good subset of , then and for some primes and and some positive integers and , so for to be a power of a prime.
Next, let denote the set of all primes, let where is the exponent of the prime in the canonical decomposition of , and notice that a maximal good subset of must be of the form for some prime and some positive integer which is not divisible by . Consequently, a maximal good subset of has elements, so a partition of into bad subsets has at least members.
Finally, notice by maximality of that the sets form a partition of into bad subsets. The conclusion follows.
Techniques
Coloring schemes, extremal argumentsInvariants / monovariantsPrime numbersFactorization techniques